Friday, February 24, 2012

Do SMART boards make the grade?

One of the hot topics in educational technology is the use of interactive white boards (IWB) such as SMART boards into the classroom.  No doubt many school districts have invested thousands of dollars into this technology relying on the idea that it will improve learning, aid in teaching, and increase student engagement.  Not to mention the pressure that schools feel to keep up with the latest technology.  While touring CNN Studios here in Atlanta, I learned that interactive white boards are now used instead of green-screens to present the weather and other graphics on the nightly news.  So clearly this technology is making its way into the mainstream.  But is it really worth is for schools to install this technology into classrooms?  Are teachers utilizing them to their full potential?  Will the technology just become obsolete in a couple of years, and replaced by something much better?  And the most important question:  do IWBs really improving student learning and achievement?



This article by Enrico Uva got me thinking.  He talks about some benefits of IWBs, such as the ability to illustrate a complex idea to students with the aid of audio/visual.  But he then highlights some practicality issues such as the small, fixed size of the IWB.  If the information is larger than the IWB size, then the teacher must scroll and this could hinder students' note taking.  The author suggests that instead of bringing in an IWB to replace the traditional white board, they could be placed in another area of the room for certain occasions when the teacher decides to use it.  (Of course, most schools won't be willing to shell out thousands of dollars per classroom on something that is only used occasionally).   The author concludes with his observations on how far we have come technologically in the last 50 years.  Just 50 years ago people were sharing one phone line among their entire family, and most of their interactions and communications were face-to-face.   Now...

"And they have push-button access to any one of hundreds of channels or millions of websites and blogs. These are all wonderful tools with great potential. Yet the number of daily waking hours and the life span has not increased. Tell me that this has not consequently reduced the amount of face-to-face contact, physical exercise and critical thinking in the general population that embraces the technologies indiscriminately. Tell me that it has not alienated the rest who avoid the new technologies entirely." -Enrico Uva

As technology increases, we must not forget that the human factor must always take precedent.  But what if IWBs can actually increase face-to-face time among teacher and students?  The teacher doesn't need to turn her back to write on the board because the notes and activities are pre-loaded into the IWB.  I think of my own teaching experience, where classroom management was a constant struggle and students sought any chance when my back was turned to misbehave.  I worked in a school with no computer in the classroom, not even an overhead projector, just me an a dry-erase marker.  Yes, I longed for a SMART board, thinking that it would help keep my students on task.  But it wouldn't have necessarily made me a better teacher.  Keeping students engaged in learning is an art.  Hopefully IWBs will become more accessible for all, and make improvements that are meant to help teachers and students alike.  They have their benefits and their limitations, but with the rate that technology is changing, in five years we might not even remember what SMART boards were.

No comments:

Post a Comment