Friday, March 30, 2012

Have you tried Rosetta Stone?

I have minimal experience with Rosetta Stone, but the one-time German class I tried was fun, entertaining, and I learned a few key phrases.  Die katze schläft.  (the cat sleeps... see?)  So I looked online for some reviews from people who had extensively used Rosetta Stone, and found Benny the language-hacking Irish polyglot.  He's a blogger who has learned many languages through a communicative approach and claims to know how to become fluent in a language in 3 months.  Ok.  But his blog is enjoyable to read and I have already extended the time it should take me to write this post by at least 45 minutes because I keep getting distracted by another interesting article.  If you're thinking about buying RS, or just feel like reading a really in-depth review like me, it's nice to hear how it has helped a language learner who is actually able to use their TL in real-life contexts.    

A new feature of RS that I was unaware of is that it can connect you to an actual teacher who will lead you in a live, interactive class.  I think this adds a lot to the program, and might help people feel better about paying as much as it costs.  On the other hand, one of the main issues that Benny the Blogger has with RS is its lack of authentic material like Podcasts and content that stretches beyond the targeted vocabulary that the learner has learned in previous sessions.  RS presents vocabulary in a way that is supported by Krashen's Input Hypothesis and Natural Order Hypothesis, which claim that we acquire language in a linear order and input is the key factor in language acquisition.  So the learner can truly go at their own pace, and is introduced to each new concept in a very intentional way.         

One of the key points that he makes in the review are the monolingual format of RS (there's no use of the target language at all), and that they solely use pictures to convey meaning.  I too have issues with a strictly monolingual format, and I sometimes just want to know a literal translation of the target form.  Clearly there are people on both sides of the debate.  

Some other important issues that are brought up include what he calls a "copy-and-paste approach for drastically different languages", culturally irrelevant photos, and their extensive research being fueled by the demand to sell more product.  I found the review incredibly thorough and helpful, and I agree with Benny that in the end, the most active and curious learner will always prevail.    RS caters to the language learner who wants to learn at their own pace and on their own terms, and this can be great for some.  Hey, if the money's not an option, why not invest in a fun program that has been meticulously developed and can help you learn a language?  But if that's not you, then you have lots of other options-- just start looking.   And if you really want to learn language, you can just do what this guy does...






No comments:

Post a Comment